As the holiday season approaches, it is not unusual for people to receive gifts from vendors and suppliers with whom they work. It may sometimes be considered a professional courtesy marking a successful business relationship. That said, there are several things that businesses, employees, and workplace investigators need to keep in mind.
What’s the big deal about getting flowers and a box of chocolates? For a former Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (“CRTC”) commissioner, it became a big deal. In 2016, a broadcaster with an application before the CRTC learned it was the CRTC Commissioner’s birthday and sent her flowers and chocolates. The gifts were not sent in connection with any official courtesy, protocol, or interaction. The federal Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner found that although she did not think the CRTC Commissioner’s decision on the application was influenced by receiving them, the gifts “might reasonably be seen to have been given to influence” her. She was, therefore, found to be in an apparent conflict of interest1. The irony of this case is that the CRTC Commissioner (who was newly appointed) was on the telephone with the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner’s office, receiving her training on the rules about gifts, when the chocolates and flowers arrived in her office. She did not ask about them because she thought they were of nominal value.
The reasons why public officials should pause, and consider getting advice, before accepting gifts apply equally to private sector boards of directors. As the Institute of Corporate Directors notes, its members must avoid any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest. Gifts should not accepted unless they: are consistent with customary business practices; are not excessive in value; cannot reasonably be construed as an inducement; and, they do not violate any laws or regulations. Accepting cash gifts is prohibited.
In the private sector, rules protecting against conflicts of interest may extend beyond the C-suite. For example, a major Canadian retail chain that has posted its Code of Conduct online prohibits its employees from accepting gifts or entertainment from a third party (e.g., supplier, customer, etc.) with whom the retailer “has, or may have, a business relationship to ensure objective business decisions.” It provides specific guidance on what gifts are and are not acceptable. For example, the Code of Conduct specifically prohibits employees from accepting: “gift baskets, holiday hampers, alcohol, gift cards, cash or cash equivalents.” However, the following are acceptable: “one-off token items of nominal value: pens, notebooks, reusable bags, logo-branded items, or non-monetary gestures such as greeting cards.”
Employees who ignore their employer’s rules and accept substantial gifts do so at their peril. An employee in a position of responsibility who accepts or solicits perks or benefits makes their employer a “hostage to a potential contractor” and destroys the trust an employer places in an employee. This can be grounds for dismissal. In Poliquin v. Devon Canada Corporation, 2009 ABCA 216 (CanLII)2, amongst other things, the employee was dismissed for accepting gifts of landscaping services and supplies from his employer’s suppliers, which was contrary to the company’s Code of Conduct.
There are several lessons to draw from this discussion.
There are good reasons for employers to include gift rules in their codes of conduct. They establish clear expectations for employees, and for those who deal with the company, as to what is and is not acceptable. These rules can be sensitive to the practices and culture within a particular industry.
If the code of conduct allows nominal gifts to be accepted, it is important to provide either a dollar value or specific examples of items that can be accepted as a gift. As the CRTC Commissioner I mention above found out, one person’s perception of what is of nominal or insignificant value may differ from another’s.
Employers should also set out a clear set of questions, as the retailer I refer to above has done, to help employees consider if accepting a gift will cause a problem – even if it does not appear to be prohibited. For example:
If questions arise about what is permitted, employees need to know who to consult if they have an interpretation question. Sometimes gifts arrive without notice. If returning a gift might cause insult, or the giver is unknown, employees should be advised who they should tell about the gift and surrender it to. If the acceptance of a gift is being investigated as a breach of a code of conduct, these very same questions need to be considered by the investigator.
These considerations apply a good framework for dealing with gifts, especially at this time of year, that are received from vendors and suppliers.